Wednesday, March 21, 2012

Ballpoint vs Rollerball Pens


We get quite a few enquiries about what a rollerball pen is and what a ballpoint pen is and what's the difference and which is the most appropriate for each person. There are actually a few important differences which affect how the pen performs and in which situations it is most happy. We'll run down a few of them here.


To sum up the way they write, a rollerball writes with a thick, vivid line. The line may smudge if you quickly run your hand over it (as it uses liquid ink) but it is a smoother pen. A Ballpoint pen generally writes a thinner, less vivid line but it does dry instantly on paper.


If you're not sure what kind of pen you write with is, it's probably a ballpoint...most pens are. But you can always do a quick test keeping the above points in mind. Both pens use the same basic mechanism, where a rolling ball at the tip of the pen is 'inked' by a reservoir above it. As you write over a page, the inked ball rolls over the paper, leaving its mark.


The main difference is the ink inside that reservoir. The ballpoint uses a viscous ink, so it's not pure liquid. This is good news in some ways but bad news in others. Because of the ink formula, it dries instantly on paper and there is no smudging. This expedient little feature (like most expedient features) is really the main reason that ballpoints are so popular. And economy of course.


But because of the ink formula, the ball is not very responsive and a lot of people find ballpoints 'scratchy'. The ink can 'skip' too...because it is not a smooth flowing, liquid ink that is running over the ball, you can end up writing with a 'naked' ball, so no ink is left on your paper. We've all had this happen! Also, the ink can dry up in the reservoir. This is why those very cheap ballpoint pens stop working even though they look like they are full of ink.


Rollerballs on the other hand use a liquid ink. Or a gel ink. We'll treat them differently here. A liquid ink rollerball basically puts a greater amount of ink onto the paper than a ballpoint. 3-4 times the amount is an instructive standard and this is why your rollerball line is so vivid and also why some rollerballs can smudge.


But they are much more smooth. This makes writing easier than it is on a ballpoint pen and also just makes your work look a bit more alive! Personally i really like a rollerball line over a ballpoint line. Rollerballs can cause a couple of problems if you are using poor quality paper. As it is a liquid ink, it can 'bleed' or 'feather' if you are using poor paper. Just grab some Rhodia and you'll be fine!


Gel ink rollerballs are the same as above but even more alive still! The nature of gel as a medium allows greater pigmentation of the ink and this just leads to a greater range of possible colours, rendered with a bit more vigor.


There are, of course, exceptions to these guidelines. Fisher Space Pen ballpoint pens, due to their refill, experience none of the heartaches advised above for ballpoint pens generally. Likewise, any rollerball, such as Retro 51 or Diplomat, which uses the Schmidt Easy Flow 9000 refill will dry instantly and doesn't smudge!


If you'd like some tips, we have Ballpoint pen care and Rollerball pen care tips online. Pens aside, writing really is a marriage of paper and ink and so your paper is really important. No matter your pen, if you're using poor quality paper you will run into problems. Likewise, if you have Rhodia or Clairefontaine paper (in particular...there is plenty of great paper out there), your pen will write like a champ!

10 comments:

  1. rollerball... i actually don't know rollerball until i saw this. 90 of the pens sold in my side of the world are all ballpoint.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love pens but I am not particular the difference between the two. Whatever kind it is, as long as it sets my mood to write I use any kind of pen.

    ReplyDelete
  3. KING OF PENS IS BIC CRYSTAL BALL POINT

    ReplyDelete
  4. I must say, now I'm in the habit of using reasonable pens (Normally just a $20 Rollerball), I actually despise using the cheap ballpoint pens most people use...

    ReplyDelete
  5. If you look at the above writing samples, the rollerballs give a more uniform, some might say monotonous line, while the ballpoint gives a bit of variation. Its not nearly the variation that a broad nib fountain pens can produce, but still its a bit of variation that makes the lines a bit more interesting. Bringing up broad fountain pens is a bit of a non sequitur on this blog anyways, since these types of pens typically bleed through field notes paper.

    Anyway, getting back to ballpoints, with practice you can actually control the line variation when you write with a cursive italic hand and it can look quite nice. Unfortunately, its much more difficult to do with a rollerball.

    And I agree with Ali above, Bics produce quite a nice ballpoint, very smooth. The crystal is ok, but its too narrow for my hands. Personally, for my field notes writings I like the 4 color Bic pen, it has almost the same diameter and feel in my hand as a parker 51 and its fun to use the different colors.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Collecting of pens is one of my hobbies. Thank you for making me happy for posting different kind of pens here. I really appreciate it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I love rollerball pens than ballpoint. I used this for my artwork at school. It's cool!

    ReplyDelete
  8. As a pen seller myself, I am always asked the difference between these two types of pens, so it is good to see that people are spreading the word! I definitely prefer rollerball but some people just want to be able to use a pen that is 15 cents.

    Some of the younger folks haven't even heard of a fountain pen, or if the have, they're actually referring to the goose feather quill pens.

    Let's keep the art of writing alive!

    http://www.handmadeformen.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. Glad to chat your blog, I seem to be forward to more reliable articles and I think we all wish to thank so many good articles, blog to share with us. where can i buy matcha green tea perth

    ReplyDelete
  10. Fountain pens, especially those made of silver have been coveted by generations of people. They make excellent gifts to congratulate someone on a new job offer, or to encourage a new graduate as they enter the workforce. Even though the general use of these instruments has been replaced by less expensive varieties, they are still desired by many who appreciate the finer things in life.campo marzio pens

    ReplyDelete